The New Diamond Order: How Lab-Grown Changed Everything De Beers Built
For more than a century, De Beers controlled not just the diamond market, but the story everyone believed about diamonds. They shaped desire, defined value, and built an empire on the idea that natural scarcity equals emotional permanence.
Today, that control is breaking—and the company is doing everything it can to make the fall look like a choice.
Â
Â
The End of an Era Built on Secrecy
De Beers’ original strength wasn’t just owning mines. It was owning information.
They built a pricing system that no one outside their network could fully see or verify. Rough stones were sold only to approved buyers, cut only by certain manufacturers, and graded within standards De Beers helped design.
That structure created what amounted to a closed-door market—a place where the buyer could never quite know how value was determined.
The mystery worked in their favor. The less transparency, the more “magic.” The more magic, the easier it was to justify a price.
For decades, that illusion worked. Diamonds felt rare, elite, and emotionally charged. But none of that came from nature—it came from management.
When Transparency Became the Threat
Then came the internet, lab-grown technology, and an entire generation raised on access to information.
Suddenly, customers could compare stones side by side, read about identical chemical composition, and see that pricing differences weren’t about rarity—they were about narrative.
For De Beers, this was the nightmare scenario: a product that looked and tested the same as theirs but could be sold with fully transparent pricing.
Lab-grown diamonds broke the one rule their monopoly relied on: keep the buyer guessing.
Â
The Lightbox Experiment—And Why It Was Never Meant to Win
In 2018, De Beers launched Lightbox, its own lab-grown brand.
On paper, it looked like progress: high-quality stones, uniform $800-per-carat pricing, and a sleek modern image.
But Lightbox was never designed to compete. It was designed to control perception.
By capping prices and refusing third-party certification, De Beers framed lab-grown diamonds as casual, inexpensive accessories—“fun, not forever.”
That label wasn’t an accident; it was strategy. If De Beers could position lab-grown as disposable, they could protect the “forever” narrative tied to mined stones.
And because Lightbox was owned by them, they controlled the data, the pricing, and the story.
Â
Â
The Strategic Shutdown
When Lightbox closed in 2025, headlines framed it as proof that lab-grown demand had fizzled.
But look closer. The market for lab-grown was booming everywhere else—independent jewelers, online retailers, even major chains were expanding.
So why would De Beers kill a profitable brand in a growing category?
Because it served a bigger purpose.
They had already gotten what they wanted: confusion.
By shutting down Lightbox themselves, they could point to its closure as “evidence” that lab diamonds were a fad.
It was a calculated sacrifice—a public failure staged by a company rich enough to weaponize loss.
De Beers didn’t lose money; they bought narrative control.
They’d rather burn their own project than let it succeed outside their control.
And with the resources they have—billions in reserves, generational influence in media, and legacy partnerships with luxury houses—they can afford to do it.
Â
Â
A Market Built on Clarity, Not Control
While De Beers worked to cloud the story, the rest of the industry moved the opposite way.
Independent brands and transparent sellers began publishing cut, clarity, and markup data openly.
Customers started understanding what they were paying for—and realizing that the emotional value of a diamond doesn’t depend on where it formed.
Today’s market looks more like a true marketplace than ever before.
Price is visible. Options are real. Buyers can finally align values, ethics, and aesthetics without guesswork.
Â
Â
What the De Beers Era Taught Us
For all their manipulation, De Beers did teach the industry something valuable: stories sell jewelry.
The difference now is that customers write their own stories.
They don’t want gatekeepers; they want context. They don’t need scarcity; they want sincerity.
That’s why lab-grown diamonds continue to grow in popularity even as traditional players try to dismiss them. They align with what modern buyers actually care about—honesty, design, and personal meaning.
Â
Â
Choosing Your Own Definition of “Real”
Both mined and lab-grown diamonds are real. The question is: which reality do you want to support?
One depends on limited information. The other depends on full transparency.
At Susan Blake Jewelry, we believe beauty shouldn’t require secrecy.
Whether you choose natural or lab-grown, you deserve to know exactly what you’re buying and why.
That’s not rebellion—that’s progress.
Explore our Lab-Grown Diamond Collection